Does Kay Jewelers Buy Back Jewelry May 2026

The new diamond jewelry you purchase must cost at least double the trade-in value of your original piece. For example, if you trade in a $1,000 ring, you must buy a new one costing at least $2,000.

You request a "Gold Exchange Packet," ship your items for free, and Kay assesses their value based on metal weight and current market rates.

Here is a review of their available "buyback" and exchange options: 1. The Diamond Trade-In Program (Most Common) does kay jewelers buy back jewelry

If you have unwanted gold or platinum jewelry, Kay has a separate program for this, though it is usually handled rather than in physical stores.

This is Kay's primary way of "taking back" jewelry. You trade in a diamond you bought from them to get credit toward a new one. The new diamond jewelry you purchase must cost

If you recently bought something and just changed your mind, you can get a full refund if you act quickly:

They typically credit you 100% of the original purchase price (minus taxes and shipping). 2. Kay Jewelers Gold Exchange Here is a review of their available "buyback"

They only pay for the metal content . They do not compensate you for diamonds or gemstones in these pieces—you are advised to have them removed before shipping.